Ok this isn’t about Gordon Lightfoot.
Good collections of the Everlys abound. But once I wised up to the bogus nature of my find, I made it a point to get the originals, and it wasn’t such an ordeal. The Cadence recordings, well I got those on a UK Pickwick release, an album called The Everly Brothers Greatest Hits Collection, which I found at A&A Records in Eaton Place.
A&A was just another franchise, with the usual top 40 selection. But that one time, maybe late 70s, they had a shipment of these UK releases, some on Pickwick, and they had a whole rack full of Quality collections, of which I’ve written before.
Anyway it was a double album, with both sides of every Cadence hit by the brothers. Can’t complain. Their Warner Brothers hits come from The Golden Hits Of The Everly Brothers, one of those albums that’s been around forever, and is still around. The collection is rounded off with Gone Gone Gone and Bowling Green, which I got somewhere else, the former off the single, the latter I think from a promotional album, but I lie after all, I replaced all the WB tracks with CD copies, picked up from Walk Right Back: The Everly Brothers On Warner Brothers, 1960 – 1969, which I got from, you guessed it, the West Kildonan Library.
In the end I have here 34 of their 36 top 100 hits - not too bad...
The Everly Brothers:
• Bye Bye Love – One of the great statements of total and complete self pity. Covers abound, notably by Simon & Garfunkel and by George Harrison. From the summer of 1957.
• I Wonder If Care As Much – Contending with difficult feelings, the deterioration of a relationship. This is heady stuff for 50s rock and roll. Jackson Browne built a whole career out of this sort of thing. The B side of Bye Bye Love, it spent a week in the top 100 in the summer of 1957.
• Wake Up Little Susie – The tale of the couple that fell asleep in the cinema, and got home super late. Uh huh. The reputation is shot. My how things change. This reached number 1 in the fall of 1957.
• Maybe Tomorrow – Not the Jim Croce song, which anyway was pretty obscure.
• This Little Girl Of Mine – And the perfect girl she is. From the winter of 1958.
• Should We Tell Him – A guy and his girl are faced with the dilemma of what to do about the other guy, told from the perspective of the other guy. The B side of This Little Girl Of Mine, it was a small hit in the winter of 1958.
• All I Have To Do Is Dream – One of the great ballads of rock and roll, sung by the brothers who alternate between unison and harmony in a way that sends chills up your spine. So many people covered this, from Richard Chamberlain to The Nitty Gritty Dirt Band. Number 1 in the spring of 1958. “Only trouble is...gee whiz…”
• Claudette – Claudette was a phone receptionist at Duffy’s Taxi, when I was a driver there so many years ago. Written and originally recorded by Roy Orbison, this was the B side of All I Have To Do Is Dream, and a hit in the spring of 1958.
• Bird Dog – A song about the guy everybody despises. Steals the guy’s chick and everything. But he had to stand on tiptoe to kiss the teacher. What age group are we singing about here? And how does his gf feel about being called “my quail?” Number 1 in the autumn of 1958. “He’s a biiiird…”
• Devoted To You – Oh wow, another great slow dance. The B side of Bird Dog and a top 10 hit in its own right in the fall of ’58. Covered by James Taylor and Carly Simon, and by the Beach Boys on their Party! album.
• Problems – I guess there’s always been this perception that kids don’t have real problems, and here are the E Brothers telling us that it just ain’t so. If the litany of difficulties doesn’t persuade you, then that incredible descending guitar figure will. From late 1958.
• Love Of My Life – This was becoming the Everly Brothers ballad formula. The B side of Problems and a hit at the same time.
• Take A Message To Mary – Guy gets nailed, doesn’t want his girlfriend (wife?) to know. Who is he protecting? From the spring of 1959. Dylan covered this on Self Portrait.
• Poor Jenny – Now this is real trouble, a date turned to disaster. Place got raided, Jenny ended up in jail. What kind of places does he take his dates to, anyway. Sounds like the relationship is over. The B side of Take A Message To Mary, from the spring of 1959.
• (‘Til) I Kissed You – Ok, kissing is alright. What’s next. From the fall of 1959.
• Oh What A Feeling – Not the Crowbar song. Another song about the deterioration of a relationship. I already mentioned Jackson Browne right? Think Late For The Sky, or Lightfoot doing If You Could Read My Mind, and then remember that this is late 50s.
• Let It Be Me – The composers of this song, Felice and Boudleaux Bryant, undoubtedly could have retired on the royalties from this song alone. Even Dylan did it. Betty Everett & Jerry Butler put it back on the chart in 1964, and Bobbie Gentry & Glen Campbell did the same in 1969. A straight love song and another great slow dance, and we hear strings here for the first time on an Everly Brothers record. From the winter of 1960.
• Since You Broke My Heart – The pain of breakup.
• When Will I Be Loved – I’ve had all the bad stuff, they sing, when does the good stuff happen. From the summer of 1960. This was a huge hit for Linda Rondstadt in 1975.
• Be Bop A Lula – This cover of Gene Vincent’s hit was the B side of When Will I Be Loved and a hit in the summer of 1960.
• Like Strangers – Another song on the theme of a love gone sour. From late 1960.
• Brand New Heartache – Every time an old flame come ‘round, it’s curtains. Yeah I’ve knows girls like that…
• I’m Here To Get My Baby Out Of Jail – A song a mother sings about her son. This was a recording that Cadence had sitting around, and they released it after the brothers had left the label. It is unadorned – the brothers singing accompanied by a lone acoustic guitar. It made the chart in the fall of 1962.
• Lightning Express – A song about a stowaway, and the suckers who believe his sad tale. The B side of I’m Here To Get My Baby Out Of Jail, featuring the same sparse arrangement.
• Cathy’s Clown – I knew a Cathy a long time ago, and a Kathy also. The Brothers' kickoff hit on Warner Brothers went to number 1 in the summer of 1960.
• So Sad (To Watch Good Love Go Bad) – It is, isn’t it. A touching song about the deterioration of a relationship. From the fall of 1960.
• Walk Right Back – A pop masterpiece, and a hit in the winter of 1961. Redone by Anne Murray in the late 70s.
• Lucille – The brothers have their own ideas about how to do Little Richard. They clean it up of course; “sister” becomes “daddy.” This was the B side of So Sad (To Watch Good Love Go Bad) and a hit in the fall of 1960.
• Stick With Me Baby – We’ll find a way, overcome the odds - optimism, as it could only exist in a rock and roll song. The B side of Temptation was a hit in the summer of 1961.
• Always It’s You – This is really All I Have To Do Is Dream redux, right down to the tremolo guitar. The B side of Cathy’s Clown, and a hit in the summer of 1960.
• Temptation – There are many songs called “Temptation” and this is one of them. Pure lust. From the summer of 1961.
• Ebony Eyes – It was that streak of death-rock that happened in the early 60s; I think it was rock and roll’s first, misguided I think, attempt to come to deal with serious subject matter, and what’s more serious than death. There was Teen Angel by Mark Dinning, there was Tell Laura I Love Her by Ray Peterson, there was Last Kiss by J. Frank Wilson, a rather late entry. And there was Ebony Eyes by The Everly Brothers. The hero of our tale was serving his country, and so he arranged to marry his girl (his “ebony eyes”) at the base, because he didn’t have time for leave, or something. And so the chaplain authorized him to “send for my ebony eyes.” I can just see them arriving in a little jar. Anyway, she dies. Her plane goes down. He knows when an announcement on the PA tells everyone who has friends or relatives on flight 103 to attend the chapel across the street. How convenient that there’s a chapel across from the airport. This soap opera, the B side of Walk Right Back, was a hit in the winter of 1961.
• Crying In The Rain – Hide how you feel, that’s how it is when you’re a guy maybe, especially if how you feel is sad. A common theme – think Tracks Of My Tears, Two Faces Have I, The Great Pretender, etc etc. From the winter of 1962.
• Don’t Blame Me – The avoidance of personal responsibility in matters of romance is seen here as an expression of fate, but the repercussions may be serious. Still, this *is* romantic. From the fall of 1961
• That’s Old Fashioned (That’s The Way Love Should Be) – The old ways are always the best? This is a brassy track, with old fashioned horn charts. From the summer of 1962.
• I’m Not Angry – Now he sure does sound angry, and the lyrics vindictive as all get out, but the singer proclaims that he’s not angry, he’s “just hurt.” And I believe him. There’s a lot of overlap there. This is a profound psychological portrait of complicated emotions. Not the Elvis Costello song.
• How Can I Meet Her – He disses her, and he wants nothing more than to meet her. Yet another exploration of complicated emotions. The B side of That’s Old Fashioned (That’s The Way Love Should Be), and a hit in the summer of 1962.
• Muskrat – This is a kind of folksong that turns up a lot; there’s a version by Buffy Ste. Marie, and one by Chilliwack, that I can think of offhand. I think both of them are called Groundhog, though. From the fall of '61, the B side of Don't Blame Me.
• Gone Gone Gone – Here is where the brothers rock out. From late 1964, they were competing with the UK bands by this point.
• Bowling Green – Their last top 100 entry, this tale of hometown nostalgia just barely snuck into the top 40 in the summer of 1967, though it reached number 1 on Toronto’s CHUM chart.